View & sort all 80+ pumpkin beer reviews
The tasting continues for 2012!
Our rating scale relates to the pumpkin beer as a whole. We rated the beer itself on a 1-10 scale and then added or subtracted based on the overall “pumpkin-ness” of the beer.
(Imperial) Pumking – Southern Tier Brewing (7/10)
Crisp IPA with a strong pumpkin aroma and initial taste. Light color, standard head. “Bewitched and brewed with pagan spirit”.
Fruit Crate Pumpkin Ale – Hermitage Brewing (4/10)
Brown ale lacking pumpkin flavor or spice. A nice change from the typical pumpkin lager, but disappointing overall.
Ace Pumpkin Cider – The California Cider Company (3/10)
Vaguely interesting at first, but the novelty wears off quickly midway through a six-pack. Too thin, too sweet, and pretty bad overall.
14 in 2011 | 3 in 2012 | 15 in 2013 | 17 in 2014 | 25 in 2015 | 9 in 2016
Pingback: The Great Pumpkin Ale Tasting - maxelman.com
Pingback: Pumpkin Ales 2013 - Max Elman